Explore our Top 10 curated Breast Shields—evaluated based on Comfort and Fit, Leak Protection and Absorbency, Safety and Materials, Ease of Use and Portability and more. Use our prompt box below to refine your need or look for additional products.
Adjustable BPA free breast pump shields multiple sizes comfort
Medela PersonalFit Breastshields
$14.72 - $16.99
LushLife Pick
Customer Sentiment
Users consistently praise improved comfort from the soft rim and flexible design, noting better milk output and fit when using correct size. Many highlight the importance of proper sizing and recommend consulting lactation professionals. A few report issues with suction or fit, especially if breast anatomy differs or tunnel length is mismatched. Overall sentiment across retailers is positive, emphasizing comfort, efficiency, and customization.
Pros and Cons
Pros
Improved milk removal efficiency (~11.8% more per minute)
Enhanced comfort from soft rim and flexible design
Customizable fit across multiple sizes
Easy to clean—dishwasher‑safe
BPA‑free, safe materials
Wide compatibility with Medela pumps
Cons
Some users report suction or fit issues depending on breast shape
Tunnel length may not suit all anatomies
Some find shields too small or uncomfortable
Sizing still requires trial or lactation consultant guidance
Key Features
FLEX™ technology with 105° opening angle
Soft, flexible rim for comfort
Oval shape rotates 360°
Available in multiple sizes (21–36 mm)
Removes ~11.8% more milk per minute
Made of BPA‑free, food‑grade polypropylene and TPE
Dishwasher‑safe (top rack)
Compatible with all Medela breast pumps
Manufactured in Switzerland, packaged in U.S.
Reusable and durable
Top Vetted Retailers
High performance energy efficient with smart technology features
Ameda Washable Skin-to-Skin Nipple Shield
$8.49
Customer Sentiment
Users consistently praise the shield’s comfort, skin‑to‑skin design, ease of cleaning, and effectiveness in improving latch, though a few note reduced milk flow or adhesion issues.
Pros and Cons
Pros
Enhances skin‑to‑skin contact while nursing
Ultra‑soft silicone offers comfort and latch support
Reusable and easy to clean (dishwasher safe)
Available in multiple sizes for better fit
High user satisfaction (4.9/5 rating)
BPA‑free and DEHP‑free for safety
Cons
May reduce milk flow rate according to some reviewers
Single unit packaging may be inconvenient for some users
Cut‑out may not adhere or stay in place for all users
Not intended for long‑term use without professional guidance
Key Features
Cut‑out design for increased skin‑to‑skin contact
Ultra‑thin, flexible silicone
Firmer nipple center for better grip
Softer surround for breast stimulation
Washable and reusable
Sterile individual packaging
BPA‑free and DEHP‑free
Encourages latch and protects sore/cracked nipples
Dishwasher safe cleaning
Multiple sizes (16 mm, 20 mm, 24 mm)
Top Vetted Retailers
Sterling silver nursing cups with antimicrobial properties included
Silverette Silver Nursing Cups
$61.90
Customer Sentiment
Users consistently report rapid healing of cracked or sore nipples, often within days, and appreciate the antimicrobial properties of silver; many note the cups are lightweight and comfortable when sized correctly; some mention visibility under clothing and moisture retention as drawbacks; a few experienced indentations or discomfort from edges, especially when worn continuously or with tight bras; overall sentiment across forums and retailer reviews is positive, emphasizing effectiveness and comfort.
Pros and Cons
Pros
Natural antimicrobial and anti‑inflammatory silver promotes healing and prevents infection
Clinically studied and FDA‑registered medical device
Lightweight and anatomically shaped for comfort
Reusable and eco‑friendly, with recycling program into keepsake charm
Available in two sizes to accommodate different areola sizes
Cons
Visible under clothing and may be awkward in public
Can trap moisture or milk, potentially causing dampness or irritation
Edges may dig into skin or cause indentations if fit or bra is tight
Some users report metallic smell or discomfort after prolonged wear
Higher price compared to gel pads or creams
Key Features
Made from 925 sterling silver, nickel‑free
Handcrafted in Italy by licensed silversmiths since 2002
FDA‑registered and clinically studied at University Hospital of Padua for two years
Anatomical, patented design with rounded apex and convex shape for air circulation and comfort
Lightweight (~3 g or 0.1 oz per cup)
Reusable indefinitely and recyclable into a keepsake charm
Available in Regular and XL sizes (based on areola diameter or bra cup size)
Eco‑friendly, no creams or lotions needed
TGA Class I registered (Australia)
Top Vetted Retailers
Ultra thin silicone nipple shields cut design storage case
Medela Contact Nipple Shields and Case
$6.44 - $6.49
Customer Sentiment
Users frequently praise the comfort of the ultra‑thin silicone and the cut‑out design that preserves skin‑to‑skin contact. The storage case is noted for hygiene and portability. Many report that the shields enabled continued breastfeeding during latch‑on challenges or tongue‑tie issues. Some mention difficulty transitioning off the shields, longer feeding times, or babies knocking them off. Correct sizing is emphasized as important for comfort and effectiveness.
Ultra thin food grade silicone nipple shields aid latching
Haakaa Silicone Nipple Shields 2-Pack
$9.99 - $13.93
Customer Sentiment
Users frequently praise the soft, body‑warming silicone and how it helped save breastfeeding journeys, especially with latch issues or tongue‑tie. The one‑piece design and included case are appreciated for hygiene and convenience. Some users report sizing mismatches or that the shield stretched over time. A few found suction too strong or experienced pain when applying. Several mention difficulty weaning off the shield or slow milk flow for their baby.
Pros and Cons
Pros
Soft, ultra‑thin silicone molds to breast and warms with body heat
Patented one‑piece design reduces crevices for bacteria
Includes protective case and two shields for convenience
Dishwasher, microwave, steam sterilizer and boil‑safe for easy cleaning
Helps with latch issues, inverted or cracked nipples
Hands‑free suction design aids feeding
Cons
Some users report sizing inconsistencies (e.g., received 18 mm instead of expected 21 mm)
May stretch out over time requiring replacement
Some find suction too strong or painful if applied incorrectly
Difficult to wean off; may inhibit return to bare‑breast latching
Reports of slow milk flow or inefficient transfer for some babies
Users consistently praise the ultra‑thin silicone and natural shape for improving latch and comfort, note the handy sterilizing box and portability, appreciate the shields’ effectiveness for sore or flat nipples, but some mention sizing confusion, occasional slipping during feeds, and the need to replace over time.
Pros and Cons
Pros
Ultra‑thin silicone allows maximum skin contact
Textured surface improves airflow and baby comfort
Includes sterilizable storage box for hygiene
Size 2 (23 mm) fits medium/large nipples
Developed with medical experts for safety
Easy to carry and discreet for on‑the‑go use
Cons
Sizing guidance is limited, may cause pinching if wrong size
Some users report sides lifting or slipping during use
Must be used under professional guidance
Needs replacement over time, adding cost
Key Features
SkinSoft™ ultra‑thin silicone surface
Butterfly/natural shape for maximum skin contact
Textured surface allows air flow
Sterilizable storage/mini‑steriliser box
Two shields per pack
Size 2 fits up to 23 mm nipples
BPA‑ and BPS‑free
Developed with medical experts
Top Vetted Retailers
Ultra thin butterfly shaped nipple shields for comfort
Philips Avent Nipple Shields
$7.99 - $13.81
Customer Sentiment
Users consistently highlight the ultra‑thin butterfly shape for improved skin‑to‑skin contact and latch support, the flow‑regulating holes for managing oversupply, and the comfort for sore nipples; sizing accuracy and inclusion of a storage case are appreciated; some note limited availability and lack of US MSRP.
Pros and Cons
Pros
Ultra‑thin design promotes skin‑to‑skin contact and bonding
Helps babies latch when facing latch‑on challenges
Protects sore, cracked or sensitive nipples
Flow control via three holes helps manage oversupply
Available in two sizes for better fit
Includes hygienic carrying case for storage
Cons
No US official pricing on Philips site
Limited independent expert reviews available
Sizing requires measuring nipple diameter
Not reusable beyond silicone lifespan
Key Features
Ultra‑thin butterfly‑shaped silicone design
Allows skin‑to‑skin contact (nose and chin)
Helps with latch‑on challenges (flat/inverted nipples, weak suck)
Three holes to regulate milk flow
Available in two sizes (small 12 mm, medium 21 mm)
BPA‑free silicone
Includes hygienic carrying case
Reusable
Top Vetted Retailers
Patented one piece soft silicone nipple shield hands free
Haakaa Silicone Breastfeeding Nipple Shield
$19.05 - $23.11
Customer Sentiment
Many users praise its effectiveness for latch difficulties, inverted or sore nipples, and transitioning from bottle to breast. Several report pain relief and successful breastfeeding resumption. Some note prolonged feeding times and occasional discomfort or pinching. A few mention challenges with milk transfer or suction, and concerns about nipple damage or clogged ducts with extended use. Overall sentiment is positive for short‑term, situational use.
Pros and Cons
Pros
Helps babies with latch difficulties latch more easily
Protects sore, cracked, or inverted nipples
Hands‑free suction allows feeding while multitasking
Anti‑colic variable flow reduces air intake and choking risk
Easy to clean and sterilise
Includes protective storage case
Cons
Can slow feeding sessions significantly
Some users report discomfort or pinching if misaligned
May inhibit milk transfer or let‑down for some babies
Potential for nipple damage or clogged ducts with prolonged use
May be bulky or awkward in public feeding situations
Key Features
Patented one‑piece design with no joints or edges
100% soft silicone, BPA/PVC/phthalate‑free
Extended teat creates space between nipple and baby’s mouth
Available round or triangle base for suction or skin‑to‑skin contact
Orthodontic (thumb‑shaped) or bottle‑style teat options
Anti‑slip ridged outer edge for grip
Variable flow/anti‑colic teat to prevent choking or air intake
Dishwasher and microwave steriliser safe
Includes protective storage case
Top Vetted Retailers
Premium organic materials with advanced safety features included
2 Nipple Shields
$7.99 - $19.49
Customer Sentiment
Users frequently report that the shields provided immediate relief from nipple pain, enabled latch when direct breastfeeding was difficult, and were easy to clean and sterilize; some note challenges with size fit, occasional slipping, and the need to wean off gradually.
Pros and Cons
Pros
Allows skin‑to‑skin contact while using a shield
Thin, flexible silicone warms to body temperature for natural feel
Includes microwave sterilizer case for hygiene and portability
Temporary tool—should be used under supervision and weaned off
Limited size options (only 20 mm and 24 mm) may not fit all users
Requires regular cleaning and sterilization
May complicate latch transition when weaning off
Key Features
100% soft silicone butterfly shape
Ultra‑thin design for skin‑to‑skin contact
Contours to natural breast shape
Microwave sterilizer travel case included
Sterilizing eliminates 99.9% of bacteria, mold, yeast
Phthalate‑free and BPA‑free
Available in two sizes (20 mm and 24 mm)
Helps with flat/inverted nipples, overactive let‑down, latching issues
Temporary use under healthcare supervision
Top Vetted Retailers
Soft organic materials with advanced leak protection features included
Lansinoh Washable Nursing Pads
$14.99 - $29.98
Customer Sentiment
Users frequently praise softness, comfort, and discreet fit; many highlight sustainability and ease of washing; some note absorbency is adequate for moderate flow but less so for heavy leakage; a few mention texture issues or visibility under clothing; wash bag convenience is appreciated though occasionally noted as small.
Pros and Cons
Pros
Soft and comfortable even for sensitive skin
Effective leak protection with three‑layer design
Contoured shape fits discreetly in nursing bras
Reusable and sustainable, reduces waste
Includes wash bag for easy laundering
Maintains shape wash after wash
Cons
Absorbency may be insufficient for heavy milk flow
