Explore our Top 10 curated Mattress—evaluated based on Safety Certifications, Comfort and Support, Durability and Ease of Use, Value for Money and more. Use our prompt box below to refine your need or look for additional products.
Dual sided breathable innerspring crib mattress with green guard certification included
Dream On Me 2-in-1 Breathable 132 Premium Coil Inner Spring Standard Crib & Toddler Mattress
$64.56 - $71.99
LushLife Pick
Customer Sentiment
Customers appreciate the reversible design for infant and toddler use, the strong safety certifications, and the easy‑clean waterproof cover. Some report excellent durability and responsive customer service. A few users mention comfort issues as the child grows or softness developing over time. Packaging damage during shipping was noted but resolved by customer support.
Pros and Cons
Pros
Reversible design supports both infant and toddler stages
Across retailers and expert reviews, customers consistently praise the mattress’s breathability, organic non‑toxic materials, dual‑stage design, waterproof and washable cover, strong edge support, and lightweight core; some note the high price, very firm feel, snug cover fit, and occasional warping or sagging concerns.
Organic, non‑toxic materials with multiple certifications
Dual‑firmness grows with child
Waterproof and easy‑clean surface
Lightweight core makes sheet changes easier
Strong edge support for toddler safety
Lifetime limited warranty and 100‑night trial
Cons
Premium price point
Cover fits snugly and may be hard to remove
Not fully organic (only cotton fiber and batting)
Some users report mattress feels very firm or hard
Key Features
360° breathable washable cover
Certified organic cotton fabric and fill (GOTS)
Waterproof surface from non‑GMO sugarcane (food‑grade)
Dual‑stage firmness: firm infant side, medium‑firm toddler side
No polyurethane foam, flame retardants, glues or adhesives
Lightweight WaveSupport™ core or optional innerspring
Strong edge support
Machine‑washable removable cover
Meets CPSC/pediatric firm support recommendations
Made in USA
Top Vetted Retailers
Breathable washable mattress with advanced safety features included
HALO Dreamweave Breathable Crib Mattress
$249.95 - $249.99
Customer Sentiment
Customers consistently praise the mattress’s breathability, washability, dual‑sided longevity, lightweight handling, and peace of mind from safety features. A few note concerns about drying time for the core, firmness being too rigid for some infants, occasional packaging damage, and the higher price point.
Pros and Cons
Pros
Exceptional breathability for airflow and comfort
Entire mattress is washable—cover and core
Dual‑sided design extends usable life into toddler years
Dual‑sided: firm infant side and waterproof toddler side
100% washable cover and core
GREENGUARD Gold certified
Hypoallergenic materials
No foam, latex, springs, glue, or added flame retardants
Eco‑friendly and 100% recyclable
Fits standard cribs (52\"×28\"×4.5\")","Lightweight for easy handling","Replacement cover available","Also fits BassiNest Swivel/Glide Sleepers
Top Vetted Retailers
Dual sided innerspring crib mattress with green guard certification and durability
Serta Tranquility Eco Firm Crib & Toddler Mattress
$129.93 - $189.99
Customer Sentiment
Across retailers and forums, customers praise the mattress’s firm support, dual‑sided longevity, safety certifications, waterproof ease of cleaning, and durability over years of use, while a minority mention slight coil feel or insufficient firmness when baby flips prone, and some note the vinyl cover can be noisy.
Pros and Cons
Pros
Dual‑sided design extends usable life from infancy to toddlerhood
Limited 35‑year (or 50‑year per some listings) warranty
Dimensions ~27.5\"×52\"×6\
Top Vetted Retailers
Dual sided breathable mattress with advanced safety features included
Dream On Me 3" Portable Crib Mattress
$25.72 - $29.98
Customer Sentiment
Users consistently praise the mattress’s lightweight portability, firm yet comfortable support, easy‑to‑clean waterproof cover, and strong value under $35. The dual‑sided design for infant and toddler stages is appreciated. Some note a plasticky feel or initial odor that dissipates with airing. A few mention it doesn’t fit pack ’n plays per spec, though some adapt it successfully.
Pros and Cons
Pros
Dual‑sided firmness adapts from infant to toddler stage
Waterproof and easy to clean vinyl cover
Lightweight and portable (~2.5 lbs)
Greenguard Gold and CPSIA certifications ensure low emissions and chemical safety
Made in USA with 10‑year limited warranty
Affordable price under $35
Cons
Not designed for standard cribs or pack ’n plays (though some users report fit)
Vinyl cover may feel plasticky or loud
Some users report initial chemical odor requiring airing out
Thickness may be too low for certain pack‑and‑play safety rail heights
Key Features
Dual‑sided design: extra‑firm infant side and cushioned toddler side
Greenguard Gold certified for low chemical emissions
Baby Safety Alliance verified and CPSIA compliant
Passes Federal Flammability Standard 16 CFR 1633
Lightweight (~2.5 lbs) and hypoallergenic
Dimensions: 38\" L × 24\" W × 3\" H for snug mini crib fit","Made in USA with 10‑year limited warranty
Top Vetted Retailers
Dual sided crib mattress with cooling gel memory foam features included
Beautyrest Black Aircool Two-Stage Crib and Toddler Mattress
$299.99
Customer Sentiment
Verified buyers consistently praise the mattress’s dual‑sided design, cooling performance, comfort, firmness appropriate for infants, waterproof cover, and overall quality, while noting its weight and price as minor considerations.
Pros and Cons
Pros
Dual‑sided design supports both infants and toddlers
Cooling gel memory foam helps regulate temperature
Pocketed coils offer durable support and pressure relief
GREENGUARD Gold and CertiPUR‑US certifications ensure low emissions and safe materials
Waterproof cover is easy to clean and protects mattress
Edge support enhances stability and safety
Cons
Higher price compared to basic crib mattresses
Weight (~26–30 lbs) may make handling less convenient
Limited independent expert reviews available
No weight capacity specified
Key Features
Dual‑sided design: firm infant side and gel memory foam toddler side
AirCool™ gel memory foam for temperature control
231 luxury pocketed coil springs for support
Argentum+ woven cover with moisture‑wicking and antibacterial silver ions
BeautyEdge foam encasement for edge support
Waterproof, medical‑grade backing
GREENGUARD Gold certified
CertiPUR‑US certified foam
Natural fire protection wrap meeting flammability standards
Limited lifetime warranty
Made in USA
Dimensions approx. 52\"×27.5\"×6\
Top Vetted Retailers
Organic breathable baby crib mattress with removable washable cover
Naturepedic Organic Breathable Baby Crib Mattress
$305.15 - $359.00
Customer Sentiment
Customers consistently praise the mattress’s breathability, organic materials, waterproofing, and ease of cleaning. Many note the firm support and dual‑stage design as beneficial for infant safety and toddler comfort. Some users report early sagging in the lightweight version or find the mattress overly firm. Overall sentiment skews positive with occasional concerns about durability or firmness.
Pros and Cons
Pros
Outstanding breathability with lab score of 2
Organic, non‑toxic materials with multiple certifications
Waterproof and easy‑to‑clean surface
Dual‑firmness supports infant to toddler transition
Lightweight version easy to lift and change sheets
Strong edge support and firm, safe sleep surface
Cons
Higher price compared to non‑organic options
Lightweight version may show early sagging or dents
Cover fit can be snug and tricky to remove
Some users find mattress very firm or hard
Key Features
GOTS‑certified organic cotton cover and fill
Removable 3D breathable washable cover
Waterproof LDPE surface made from non‑GMO sugarcane
WaveSupport™ lightweight core or 252‑coil innerspring option
Excellent edge support
No flame retardants, glues, polyurethane foam, PVC, phthalates
Breathability score of 2 (lab tested)
Lifetime warranty and 100‑night trial
Made in USA
Top Vetted Retailers
Premium water resistant mattress with excellent safety certifications included
Graco Basics 5-Inch Crib & Toddler Mattress
$109.99 - $113.91
Customer Sentiment
Customers consistently praise the mattress’s safety certifications, easy‑to‑clean cover, firm yet comfortable support, affordability, and US manufacturing; some mention initial chemical odor, firmness concerns, and lack of dual‑sided design.
Pros and Cons
Pros
Strong safety certifications including GREENGUARD Gold and Baby Safety Alliance Verified
Free from fiberglass and chemical flame retardants
Made in USA with U.S. and imported materials
Top Vetted Retailers
Fully breathable washable crib mattress with GREENGUARD Gold certification
Newton Baby Crib Mattress
$299.99 - $300.00
Customer Sentiment
Customers consistently praise the mattress’s breathability, washability, and peace‑of‑mind safety benefits; many note the washable core and covers make cleanup easy; some mention the premium price but justify it for hygiene and longevity; a few report concerns about fit tightness or drying time after washing.
Customers consistently praise the mattress’s safety certifications, dual‑sided design, and durability. The waterproof cover is appreciated for hygiene, though some report noise or zipper issues. Fit in standard cribs is generally snug, but compatibility with mini cribs can be problematic. The firm infant side is seen as supportive, though a few find it too hard. Overall, value is seen as strong given the long warranty and build quality.
Pros and Cons
Pros
GREENGUARD Gold certification ensures low VOCs and safer indoor air
Dual‑sided design grows with child from firm infant to softer toddler side
Waterproof and tear‑resistant cover enhances durability and hygiene
Long 25‑year warranty offers strong value and peace of mind
Lightweight for easy sheet changes and handling
Made in USA supports quality and domestic manufacturing
Cons
Some users report cover noise or friction sound disturbing infants
May not fit non‑standard or mini cribs (e.g., Delta mini)
Firm infant side may feel too hard for some babies
No foam layer may reduce cushioning comfort for some toddlers
Key Features
GREENGUARD Gold certified for low chemical emissions
Dual‑sided: firm infant side and cushier toddler side
160‑coil innerspring core with polyester fiber fill
Waterproof, tear‑resistant cover
Free of polyurethane foam, vinyl, chemical flame retardants
Meets CA 1633 flammability without chemical retardants
