Explore our Top 10 curated Teething Gels—evaluated based on Safety Features, Effectiveness Relief, Ease of Use, Value for Money and more. Use our prompt box below to refine your need or look for additional products.
USDA organic certified gel with excellent natural ingredients
Hyland's Baby Organic Soothing Gel Daytime
$6.99 - $23.99
LushLife Pick
Customer Sentiment
Parents consistently praise its organic, benzocaine‑free formula, pleasant cherry flavor, easy fingertip application, cooling effect when refrigerated, and effectiveness in calming teething fussiness during the day.
Pros and Cons
Pros
Certified organic and free from benzocaine, dyes, sugar
Includes calming botanicals like chamomile, calendula, fennel
Pleasant organic cherry flavor that babies accept
Easy to apply with fingertip or cotton applicator
Refrigeration adds cooling soothing effect
Made in the USA
Cons
Small 0.53 oz tube may run out quickly
Daytime‑only formula may require separate nighttime product
Premium organic plant based teething relief with excellent safety
Boiron Camilia Teething Relief
$10.62 - $12.49
Customer Sentiment
Many parents appreciate the hygienic, portable format and benzocaine‑free formula, noting it calms babies quickly; others question its efficacy, calling it essentially water or placebo; some report it helps reduce redness or fussiness within minutes; concerns include lack of scientific support and limited duration of effect; overall sentiment is mixed between convenience and skepticism.
Does not numb gag reflex or interfere with nursing
Hygienic and mess‑free administration
Recyclable LDPE vials
Recommended for babies 1 month and older
Available in boxes of 15 or 30 doses
Winner of Mom’s Choice Award®
Top Vetted Retailers
USDA certified organic gel with excellent natural ingredients
Mommy's Bliss Organic Little Gums Soothing Massage Gel
$12.29 - $14.99
Customer Sentiment
Many parents praise its organic, gentle formulation and pleasant taste, noting it calms babies quickly, especially at night. The dual day/night design and optional refrigeration are appreciated. However, some find the tube size too small and the effect too mild, with a few reporting no relief or adverse reactions like headaches. Overall sentiment leans positive for natural relief, with caveats about strength and quantity.
Pros and Cons
Pros
USDA‑certified organic ingredients and clean‑label formulation
Dual day/night gels tailored for different needs
Free of benzocaine and other harsh chemicals
Pleasant mild sweet taste that infants accept
Optional cooling when refrigerated
Generally effective soothing according to many users
Cons
Small tube size may run out quickly
Some users report limited or no relief
Not as strong as medicated gels for numbing
A few users reported adverse reactions like headaches or irritation
Key Features
USDA‑certified organic day and night gels
Free of benzocaine, belladonna, numbing agents
Free of parabens, artificial colors, flavors, sugar
Free of top 9 allergens
Contains organic chamomile, ginger, fennel, thyme, vanilla; night adds lemon balm and passionflower
Sugar‑free and drug‑free
Pea‑sized application, up to 9 times per 24 hours
Optional refrigeration for cooling effect
Top Vetted Retailers
+1
High quality non medicated gel with excellent safety features
Baby Orajel Non-Medicated Cooling Gel for Teething
$7.00 - $10.59
Customer Sentiment
Users consistently praise the instant cooling relief and clean, drug‑free formula; many note the nighttime chamomile version helps soothe babies to sleep; small tube size is a common concern; some report temporary effect requiring reapplication; a few mention difficulty dispensing or empty tubes; overall sentiment is positive with minor caveats.
Pros and Cons
Pros
Drug‑free and benzocaine‑free, reducing risk of methemoglobinemia
Instant cooling sensation provides quick soothing
Includes both daytime and nighttime formulas (nighttime has chamomile)
Clean ingredient profile free of common allergens and additives
Highly rated by users across platforms
Small amount goes a long way
Cons
Small tube size means limited quantity per purchase
Relief is temporary and may require frequent reapplication
Some users report difficulty dispensing gel or empty tubes
A few users cite chemical taste or concern over ingredients
Not universally effective—some babies show minimal response
Includes daytime and nighttime (with chamomile) gels
Instant cooling sensation
For babies 3+ months
Apply up to 4 times daily
Small pea‑size application via fingertip or applicator
Drug‑free soothing option
Top Vetted Retailers
Gentle organic formula with advanced safety features included
Ashton & Parsons Teething Gel
$37.60
Customer Sentiment
Across retailers and forums, parents consistently praise the gel’s gentle, non‑anaesthetic formula, hygienic brush applicator, fast soothing effect, suitability for sensitive infants, and trusted heritage, while noting that relief may be short‑lived and applicator safety requires attention.
Pros and Cons
Pros
Gentle, non‑anaesthetic formula suitable for sensitive infants
Free from lactose, sugar, alcohol—good for dietary sensitivities
Trusted brand with 150 years heritage
Convenient pea‑sized dosing and clear instructions
Cons
Applicator may detach—safety caution needed
Not a toy—risk if left unsupervised
Some users find relief short‑lived compared to powder
Availability may be limited in some physical stores
Key Features
Forms invisible barrier film on gums
Soft silicone‑bristle brush applicator
Free from lactose, sugar, alcohol, local anaesthetics
Contains soothing Aloe Vera
Suitable for infants aged 3 months and above
Apply pea‑sized amount, massage gums, use 3‑4 times daily
Single‑patient tube to avoid cross‑contamination
Medical‑device classification, not a toy
Top Vetted Retailers
Gentle natural tooth gel with excellent organic ingredients
Jack N' Jill Baby Gum and Tooth Gel
$16.23
Customer Sentiment
Parents appreciate the natural, soothing ingredients and mild flavor, find it easy to apply and safe for early oral care, though some note the relief is short‑lived and wish for a larger tube.
Baby Orajel Daytime & Nighttime Cooling Gels for Teething
$5.90 - $17.30
Customer Sentiment
Many parents praise the instant cooling relief and appreciate the dual‑formula convenience. The drug‑free, benzocaine‑free formulation reassures caregivers. Some users note the tubes contain minimal product, limiting usage. A few report that relief is short‑lived or inconsistent across children. Occasional adverse reactions like vomiting or reflux are mentioned. Overall sentiment leans positive, with concerns centered on quantity and variable effectiveness.
Pros and Cons
Pros
Drug‑free and benzocaine‑free, reducing risk of methemoglobinemia
Fast acting natural teething gel with excellent safety features
Dr. Talbot's Baby Tooth Gel
$5.94 - $11.98
Customer Sentiment
Users across retailers appreciate the natural, non‑toxic formulation and ease of use; many note fast but sometimes brief relief; caregivers value the inclusion of calming botanicals; price is seen as affordable; some mention limited duration of effect; a few express uncertainty about its overall efficacy compared to other teething remedies.
Pros and Cons
Pros
Natural, swallow‑safe formula without benzocaine or belladonna
Includes calming botanicals (chamomile, clove, marigold)
Fast‑acting relief reported by users
Made in USA
Affordable price point
Includes silicone massaging toothbrush in some bundles
Cons
Relief may be short‑lived per some user reports
Some caregivers uncertain about efficacy compared to other methods
Limited clinical testing or certifications noted
Potential for allergic reaction to botanical ingredients
Includes silicone massaging toothbrush (in some bundles)
Top Vetted Retailers
Gentle homeopathic gel with textured teether for soothing relief
Dr. Talbot's Soothing Gel for Sore Gums
$4.97 - $7.29
Customer Sentiment
Many caregivers appreciate the teether’s texture and find it soothing for infants; several note the gel is safe to swallow and non‑toxic; some report fast calming effects; others say the gel has minimal numbing effect; a few mention packaging inconsistencies or concerns about choking hazard if teether is damaged; overall sentiment is mixed but leans positive regarding teether and safety.
Pros and Cons
Pros
Non‑toxic, benzocaine‑ and belladonna‑free formula
Includes a soft silicone teether that infants enjoy
Safe to swallow and made in USA
Dishwasher‑safe and easy to clean
Conforms to US toy safety standards
Affordable price point
Cons
Gel effectiveness varies—some users report little to no numbing effect
Some packaging inconsistencies in ingredients listing
Potential choking hazard if teether is chewed through
Homeopathic claims not FDA‑evaluated
Key Features
0.53 oz gel with bonus Nuby Gum‑EEZ teether
Benzocaine‑free
Belladonna‑free
Paraben‑free
Homeopathic active ingredients (Arnica montana, Calcarea phosphorica, Chamomilla)
Safe to swallow
Includes soft silicone massaging toothbrush/teether
BPA‑free
Made in USA
Conforms to ASTM F963 toy safety standard and meets CPSC requirements
Directions: pea‑size application every 15 min as needed
